Who would be the 2024 NASCAR champion without playoffs?

Joey Logano claimed the championship after a strong performance in the final race, but the criticisms of the current system have not been long in coming. For many, the format does not adequately reward consistency throughout the season, a recurring theme since the implementation of the playoffs in 2004. Designed to ensure competitiveness until the end, this system has divided opinions among analysts and fans about whether it truly reflects sporting justice.

The Origin of the Playoff System

The creation of the playoff system was a response to the dominance of certain drivers who, after strong seasons, had already clinched the championship several races before the final. In an effort to keep the audience engaged until the last race, NASCAR adopted a format where a group of drivers competes for the title in the final rounds. While the goal of maintaining public interest was achieved, the format has been criticized, with detractors arguing that it favors one-time performance over sustained effort throughout the championship.

Consistency vs. Performance in the Final Race

One of the strongest arguments against the playoff system is the lack of recognition for consistency. This became evident in the 2024 season when some of the most consistent drivers failed to qualify for the "Championship 4", despite showing strong performances throughout the season. Below is a comparison of the final results under the playoff format versus a hypothetical cumulative points system:

Results under the 2024 Playoff System:

Position	Driver	Points	Difference
1	Joey Logano	5040
2	Ryan Blaney	5035	-5
3	William Byron	5034	-6
4	Tyler Reddick	5031	-9
5	Christopher Bell	2412	-2628
6	Kyle Larson	2378	-2662
7	Chase Elliott	2342	-2698
8	Denny Hamlin	2328	-2712
9	Alex Bowman	2318	-2722
10	Martin Truex Jr	2257	-2783

Results under a Cumulative Points System 2024:

Position	Driver	Points	Difference
1	Kyle Larson	1189
2	Christopher Bell	1167	-22
3	Chase Elliott	1163	-26
4	William Byron	1138	-51
5	Tyler Reddick	1107	-82
6	Ryan Blaney	1086	-103
7	Denny Hamlin	1072	-117
8	Alex Bowman	982	-207
9	Martin Truex Jr	951	-238
10	Brad Keselowski	944	-245

Fan Opinions and Audience Impact

The current format has divided opinions. The fact that a driver can lose the championship due to an incident in a single decisive race causes dissatisfaction, particularly among more traditional fans.

As for the audience, 2024 data did not show a significant increase over previous seasons during the final in Phoenix, which has led NASCAR to consider a possible revision of the format. Any major change would be implemented at the earliest in 2026, to avoid affecting sponsors and broadcast partners.

A Manipulable System

The playoff system has also revealed a vulnerability to unsportsmanlike maneuvers. In 2024, Austin Dillon was penalized for intentionally causing a collision with Joey Logano and Denny Hamlin in Richmond, which had initially secured him a direct spot in the playoffs. NASCAR's subsequent review resulted in his elimination from the playoffs and the suspension of Dillon's spotter.

The pressure from the current format encourages desperate and dangerous actions. In Martinsville, Christopher Bell attempted to replicate the "Hail Melon" maneuver to gain positions due to the need to secure his spot in the final rounds, leading him to make risky decisions. NASCAR determined that these actions jeopardized safety, penalizing Bell and excluding him from the "Championship 4."

Additionally, in Martinsville, several drivers appeared to deliberately favor their teammates in an effort to help them advance in the standings. These cooperation tactics were viewed as unsportsmanlike and compromising the integrity of the championship. NASCAR ended up imposing penalties on drivers such as Bubba Wallace and Ross Chastain, with fines and point deductions for violating the series' conduct policies.

A Not-So-New Problem

The big challenge for NASCAR lies in finding the balance between competitiveness and fairness. No format will please everyone, as there will always be differences in how the champion should be determined. Over the years, NASCAR has implemented several systems to decide the champion, and each has had its detractors. Whether it was because some drivers dominated with too much advantage, others won without being considered the best throughout the season, or because consistency was not always rewarded, criticism has always existed. This makes it clear that any format is susceptible to being strategically exploited by those who understand its rules and weaknesses. There will always be those who find ways to take advantage of the system, and that is part of the nature of any competitive format. Logano and Team Penske seem to have made the most of the opportunities under the current system. This situation will need to be carefully analyzed, ensuring fairness for the drivers and transparency in the championship, without compromising public interest.